CHIPS Articles: Critical Infrastructure Protection for Naval Warfighters

Critical Infrastructure Protection for Naval Warfighters
By Cdr. Lynne Gaudreau, USN - October-December 2001
We have all been reading about the increasing number of cyber attacks in today's news, with increasingly more menacing—and successful "worms" dispensed against government and industry networks. As alarming as these attacks are, they represent just one aspect of the dramatically changing nature of modern-day vandalism and, on a larger scale, modern day warfare.

Ensuring operational readiness for Naval warfighters within this changing environment has led, via National and DoD initiatives, to the formation of the Department of the Navy's Critical Infrastructure Protection (DON CIP) Program.

Today's Defense Environment Emphasized the Need for CIP

The world of the black and white, bipolar balance of power that shaped our defense efforts in years past is gone. We now face a new, more insidious threat called asymmetric warfare. This new brand of warfare is unconventional, and brings the danger of being promulgated not only by large or small groups, but by just a single person with a computer and modem.

As the threat has grown in complexity, so has the business of national defense. Today, our defense establishment includes the following realities:

•Over 90% of the services required for day to day and war fighting operations of defense components now come from the private/commercial sector. (Many were previously "inherently governmental.")
•Mergers and acquisitions within the international defense industry have led to the globalization of weapon systems sustainment.
•Old defense mechanisms are no longer sufficient.

These realities, with the increasing potential for asymmetric/unconventional warfare, led to the 1998 approval and release of Presidential Decision Directive/NSC-63 (PDD-63) titled "Critical Infrastructure Protection."

PDD-63 initiated the CIP evolution.

What is DON Critical Infrastructure Protection?

Critical infrastructures are those physical and cyber-based systems needed to operate the economy and government. These systems include telecommunications, energy, banking and finance, transportation, water systems, and emergency services—both government and private. As part of National/DoD implementation of PDD-63, the DON CIP program was designed to develop, administer, and coordinate an enterprise-wide CIP effort.

For the Department of the Navy, CIP is a comprehensive, enterprise-wide initiative to:

Identify infrastructures, both cyber and physical, essential to Naval warfighters
Assess their vulnerability to loss
Develop a coordinated physical and cyber indications and warnings capability against acts of terrorism, natural disaster, or error
Take necessary action to ensure achievement of Navy/Marine Corps objectives during critical infrastructure loss.

Each of these six phases has its own set of activities, summarized in Table 1.

DON CIP Goals Flow From DON Policy

There are six primary DON CIP Goals, each with its own separate set of implementing actions and organizational leads.

DON CIP GOALS

•Ensure the Development of an Integrated CIP Capability
•Support the Development of Sector Assurance Plans
•Integrate the Efforts of Other Related DON Programs Into CIP
•Support the Development of an Integrated Indications and Warning Capability
•Establish a Web-Based Clearinghouse for DON CIP Specific Information and Guidance
•Establish Long Term Programmatic Objectives for DON CIP

Achieving these goals involves teamwork from many quarters. Key participants include:

DON CIO, Navy and Marine Corps Infrastructure Leads, Naval Criminal Investigative Service (NCIS), Headquarters Marine Corps Security and Law Enforcement Branch, Fleet Information Warfare Cen

Table 1 shows critical infrastructure protection activities.  Activity: infrastructure analysis and assessment.  Description: coordinated identification/characterization fo DON, DoD, National and International critical assets, their system and infrastructure configuration and characteristics and the dependencies among infrastructure sectors; assessment of vulnerabilities. Activity: remediation.  Description: deliverate preventative measures undertaken to improve reliability, availability and survivability of critical assets and infrastructures. Activity: indications and warning. Description: tactical indications through implementation of sector monitoring and reporting, strategic indications through Intelligence Community support, and warning in coordination with the National Infrastructure Protection Center (NIPC) in concert with existing DoD and national capabilities. Activity: Mitigation. Description: Preplanned and coordinated reactions to infrastructure warning and/or incidents designed to reduce or minimize impact; support and complement emergency, investigation, defense, or other crisis management response and facilitate reconstitution. Activity: response. Description: coordinated emergency, law enforcement, investigation, defnese or other crisis management service aimed at the source/cause of the incident. Response to DON critical infrastructure incidents will follow one of two pahts: (1) affected components and/or joint task force for computer network defense (JTF-CND) will defend against/respond to all cyber incidents in accordance with granted authorities and established operational provedures or (2) affected components will defend against/respond to all non-cyber incidents in accordance with granted authorities and established operational procedures. Activity: reconstitution. Description: owner/operator directed restoration of critical assets and infrastructure.
Table 1. Critical Infrastructure Protection Activities.
Related CHIPS Articles
Related DON CIO News
Related DON CIO Policy
CHIPS is an official U.S. Navy website sponsored by the Department of the Navy (DON) Chief Information Officer, the Department of Defense Enterprise Software Initiative (ESI) and the DON's ESI Software Product Manager Team at Space and Naval Warfare Systems Center Pacific.

Online ISSN 2154-1779; Print ISSN 1047-9988